Sunday, September 23, 2007

Repeating history?

Dada's May 2007 photo of an El Paso neighborhood living under the
cloud of the possible reopening of a major smelting company that
has already polluted our city into a Super Fund clean-up site status.
Note the cloud this neighborhood of west El Paso is living under.


As I type this my wife and her mother are protesting the reopening of a major metals refining operation here in El Paso. Lots has happened since it closed after the price of copper dropped in 1999: 1.) the company went bankrupt, 2.) El Paso was declared a super fund clean-up site as a result of the contamination around the area of this refinery; 3.) many houses in neighborhoods around the University there had their yards dug up and replaced because of soil contamination from heavy metals such as arsenic and lead (this process continues today; 4.) it was learned this refinery has also burned hazardous wastes in its furnaces and released them through their smokestacks over the city of El Paso.

Flash back with me to the mid-1970's when my wife and I were struggling students trudging over the hills of the University of Texas, El Paso between classes, breathing the toxic fumes heavy in sulfur content that formed an acid when inhaled into one's lungs or swallowed as a kind of between classes toxic "snack".

One of my very favorite fellow art department classmates was a funny girl who made everyone laugh. Her likable husband was a chemist for this refinery just a mile or so from campus. Nice people.

One particular engagement with this delightful couple stands out in my and Mrs. Dada's mind. It was the evening we were invited to their home with several other art majors and their spouses on the grounds of this refinery where they lived in a company house.

Now, I'd like to present to any readers still with me, a satellite picture of the grounds of this refinery.
Please note the blackened earth that resulted from its operation. This is the shock my wife and I experienced that night when we visited our friends in what we can only compare to a visit to another planet. Everything we saw in their company town's neighborhood was black! No yards with green grass. No shubbery, no trees. It was as if we were visiting Mars, or worse, a more formidable planet. It made us both extremely uneasy.

Now El Pasoans are fighting the reopening of this polluter. Frankly, while Dada is hopeful the public succeeds once and for all in nailing the lid shut on the coffin of this polluter forever, I am not optimistic.

Oh, and of my art department friend and her husband who lived on dead earth grounds of this company town? We learned my they have divorced. And while I've no idea if her time residing on the dead Earth of this refinery played a role, but we were shocked to learn she had become a victim of multiple sclerosis.

And now we're preparing to repeat the cycle? Let us pray not.

8 comments:

Fran said...

Whoah! This photo looks like death itself. The neighborhood would do well to find Environmental lawyers to fight this atorocity from opening again. Jeez! Maybe they thought all the inhabitants had passed away, so no one would remember it is a Superfund site? Use both local & national media if you can. Crazy how the locals have to fight to have health/quality of life-- but really you ARE fighting for your lives. With elections coming up, may be a good time to see who will be supportive re this issue? Oy!

enigma4ever said...

ahhh dada...my heart aches for you and mrs...this is horrendous...and yes, the photo is enough to make anyone know that this is not viable option or History that needs repeating....Environmental lawyers ???? are there such a thing under this Regime?

Fran said...

Sure enough-- The University of Oregon has an Environmental Law specialty department in the Law School. I'm sure there must be others, Nationwide. They exist in the **private sector**... forget the govmnt-- although you may do well to visit with the EPA and other entities that oversaw this thing before & as it became a Superfund site.
You wold be amazed at the stuff you can find by digging around in their files. If they are not readily available, you can request them under FOIA laws- Freedon of Information Act. Do the digging in files early for obvious reasons.

Anonymous said...

I'm assuming the price of copper has now increased so as to make reopening this nightmare profitable? Whether it is a private company or some kind of govt project (or combo thereof) that is contemplating reviving ASARCO, the fact that they aren't allowing public input says it all. My sympathies to the good people of El Paso and beyond, for I cannot believe air quality will not be affected in a much broader area.

If you are being denied public input, I can only hope that the public will hold their own hearings, that your press will cover them, and that enough hard questions will cast the doubt necessary to stall or end this project.

As you know, when we faced the revival of tactical nuke testing here, Utah Nevada & Idaho all held public hearings. Govt agencies glossy promo & phony science boilerplate did not deter the victims of previous nuking (those who were still alive as well as those who told family stories of the dead). Their stories were recorded into public record. Follow-up email & letter campaigns snowed the NNSA & DTRA. We did not even have to recruit EPA or lawyers. End result: indefinite postponement. It can be done!

I truly wish El Pasoans the ability to prevail. Your very lives depend on it! My heart goes out to your good friend who is now suffering MS. ~~ D.K.

Anonymous said...

Much luck to you and El Paso's residents. Though I'm obviously speaking for my own family as much as for yours, I can't imagine a return to the awful clouds of sulfur that used to hang over UTEP, Kern Place, and 'smelter town'.

ASARCO must remain closed. Even the refineries on the East Side haven't done as much damage to the surrounding area.

Dada said...

Thank you all for the comments of anger and concern. I have been offline for over 24 hours or would have responded a little sooner.

But let me just say, the decision to be handed down by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality is due very soon--next month most likely. And from what has come down, I am very pessimistic. (TCEQ) has said they would NOT be influenced by anti-refinery public input this past summer.

Yet I shall continue to hope. El Paso and two other communities have come out against the restart-up of this monster. Our mayor, and state rep have denounced it.

So as my wife and a goodly number of others gathered for a group photo in front of the refinery yesterday eve--to be presented to TCEQ, know that earlier in the day a group of citizens starred in a video produced by ASARCO to run in spots on TV in hopes of influencing TCEQ to permit its resurrection.

It's late in the game. We shall see. Thanks everyone for your comments.

Fran said...

You might even get an Environmental lawyer to work pro bono on this because of the Superfund history, this might be a juicy lawsuit. ow about retaining the lawyer from the Erin Brockovitch story? They are in California....
Ed Massey is his name....
Get to the files right away & make copies- the types of chemicals used & degree of contamination are rock solid arguments to shut this thing down- literally, for good. Enviro lawyers use these facts & bring in health science pros to make the case. Worth making some calls about & start doing your own research.

Dada said...

Fran: Great suggestions. It's obvious you'd be a great addition to any staff of activists drawing up strategies to fight powers that be.

I passed your comment along to the local ACORN "chapter" that has been spearheading the drive to stop this insanity.